Rogue Impersonation Skill - NOT A BUG!!!

[SK]Paddo · **Joined:** Apr 2007 **Posts:** 466 **Location:**

+1. besides, its just a question if you can actually stop your rampages @ pvps or actually search for someone to have a cool fight with. i rarely pvp without asking be4, so it wouldnt be such a great deal to have a fast look at the buffs.

mmsicis · **Joined:** Apr 2007 **Posts:** 615

i think it would be better to have icon next to characters name when hes wearing pvp cape. Like hunter thief trade. i saw rogue in thief masked as pvp...
Rogues... I hate them..

UniQ · **Posted:** Thu Aug 09, 2007 9:13 pm

so if you're right, why cant we attack them while jobbing?
i think its a bug, because being a murderer must be your own Farking decision... (just like unquiping a cap while someone attack you and he's a little bit late)

Dudez0r · **Joined:** Apr 2007 **Posts:** 214 **Location:**

Aiyas wrote:

CobbZ wrote:

The rogue skill of impersonating another player is not bugged.

The whole point is to impersonate someone else, wether they are wearing a cape or not. Its to make you think the rogue is someone else.

Therefore, trying to hide. If you kill the rogue, thinking they are someone else, then you have to deal with the shock and surprise of becoming murderer.

The point of the skill is do that. Not intentionally to make murderer, but thats the basic principle of it.

:::EXAMPLE:::

A robber has just robbed a house. A homeless man attacks the robber and steals his "nice" clothes. Little does he know, the police are out to kill the robber.

The police kill the man in the robber's clothes, see it isnt actually him, and so have to deal with the consequences.

THATS THE POINT OF THIS SKILL!!!

So get it into your heads, the skill is here to stay, and will not be "fixed".

Just check the players buffs ffs.

Until such time as Joymax makes a statement on this, topics like these are meaningless.

Well they kinda did on Babel, A well known silk assistant made some globals about it she said it wasn't a bug and to just look at the skills

I never can spell her name -.-

Aiyas · **Posted:** Thu Aug 09, 2007 11:33 pm

Dudez0r wrote:

Aiyas wrote:

CobbZ wrote:

The rogue skill of impersonating another player is not bugged.

The whole point is to impersonate someone else, wether they are wearing a cape or not. Its to make you think the rogue is someone else.

Therefore, trying to hide. If you kill the rogue, thinking they are someone else, then you have to deal with the shock and surprise of becoming murderer.

The point of the skill is do that. Not intentionally to make murderer, but thats the basic principle of it.

:::EXAMPLE:::

A robber has just robbed a house. A homeless man attacks the robber and steals his "nice" clothes. Little does he know, the police are out to kill the robber.

The police kill the man in the robber's clothes, see it isnt actually him, and so have to deal with the consequences.

THATS THE POINT OF THIS SKILL!!!

So get it into your heads, the skill is here to stay, and will not be "fixed".

Just check the players buffs ffs.

Until such time as Joymax makes a statement on this, topics like these are meaningless.

Well they kinda did on Babel, A well known silk assistant made some globals about it she said it wasn't a bug and to just look at the skills

I never can spell her name -.-

I thought they got rid of the Silk Assistants.

Bai · **Joined:** Jun 2007 **Posts:** 292

XemnasXD wrote:

ZOMG TY SO MUCH FOR MAKING THIS THREAD

*sarcasm*

i don't think we need a thread to tell us something thats widely known.....this won't stop ppl from crying about getting murder status...realize that

Your avatar is killing me

XemnasXD · **Posted:** Fri Aug 10, 2007 1:25 am

ping_lo · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 911 **Location:**

b0nj0vi wrote:

yeah right, so JM made a skill for the sole purpose of making someone else murderer. :roll:

someone said it best, no point debating about this until JM posts its response. But seriously, the logic of some of you ppl is truly ridiculous.

It has lots of other purposes. It just happens that one of the more fun ones involves letting high level nubs go murderer on you. It is really handy to use it to dupe someone not in cape when you are cape fighting too. But then splash does hit you.

ping_lo · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 911 **Location:**

mmsicis wrote:

i think it would be better to have icon next to characters name when hes wearing pvp cape. Like hunter thief trade. i saw rogue in thief masked as pvp...
Rogues... I hate them..

But we luv you nubkins. :love:

ping_lo · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 911 **Location:**

UniQ wrote:

so if you're right, why cant we attack them while jobbing?
i think its a bug, because being a murderer must be your own Farking decision... (just like unquiping a cap while someone attack you and he's a little bit late)

It still is your decision. Check the buffs or not. Attack or not. All the decisions are yours. They can make you do nothing you don't want to do. Just be sure what you think you want to do you really do and you will be ok.

Aiyas · **Posted:** Fri Aug 10, 2007 3:31 am

CobbZ wrote:

b0nj0vi wrote:

It is very simple logic.

If you can kill someone without holding down the 'Alt' key and end up in murder status, then it is a bug.

Anyone who says otherwise is an idiot. Period.

Wrong.........

Thats the point of the skill.

I sincerely hope you're joking.

XemnasXD · **Posted:** Fri Aug 10, 2007 3:36 am

wow ping 3 post ina row...why didn't you just edit/delete and fit it all into one

b0nj0vi · **Joined:** Aug 2006 **Posts:** 153 **Location:**

Aiyas wrote:

CobbZ wrote:

b0nj0vi wrote:

It is very simple logic.

If you can kill someone without holding down the 'Alt' key and end up in murder status, then it is a bug.

Anyone who says otherwise is an idiot. Period.

Wrong.........

Thats the point of the skill.

I sincerely hope you're joking.

like i said, some ppl have the most twisted logic. 99% of the problems in the world today are because of ppl with screwed up logic.

@ping_lo
Yes, im sure there are many uses for this skill as designed by JM. but com'on, hand on heart, do you honestly think JM intended this skill to be used to make someone else murder?? i mean, com'on man, are ppl really that dillusional?

TOloseGT · **Joined:** Sep 2006 **Posts:** 7129 **Location:**

yea...why would they intentionally make a skill just for murder when u can press alt for that?

Amelie · **Posted:** Fri Aug 10, 2007 7:05 am

TOloseGT wrote:

yea...why would they intentionally make a skill just for murder when u can press alt for that?

lazy world

5581 · **Joined:** Jun 2007 **Posts:** 87

b0nj0vi wrote:

It is very simple logic.

If you can kill someone without holding down the 'Alt' key and end up in murder status, then it is a bug.

Anyone who says otherwise is an idiot. Period.

agree, cos duplicate a cape enemy is ok, but you only have the look and not really wearing a cape, when people attack you must hold Alt key. i feel this skill just wasting sp. want pvp? invisible and kill, end of story.

UniQ · **Posted:** Fri Aug 10, 2007 11:23 am

ping_lo wrote:

UniQ wrote:

so if you're right, why cant we attack them while jobbing?
i think its a bug, because being a murderer must be your own Farking decision... (just like unquiping a cap while someone attack you and he's a little bit late)

It still is your decision. Check the buffs or not. Attack or not. All the decisions are yours. They can make you do nothing you don't want to do. Just be sure what you think you want to do you really do and you will be ok.

if it's not a bug, it must also work with the caravan system.
Its just a bug and joymax doesnt care... (like always)

Silkroad Online Forums

Rogue Impersonation Skill - NOT A BUG!!!

Who is online