Dilemma :/

Shimrod · **Joined:** Feb 2007 **Posts:** 336 **Location:**

Imagine you’re a member of small guild with only a few really active members (some have multiple chars) and some of those members are also well known to you in real life.
They have a lot of fun in guild chat and help eachother when necessary. And what’s important they are legits.
Now this guild is part of a Union with a lot of botters (some of them are proud of the fact if you read the union chat). What would you do?
Leave the guild thus abandoning your mates and join a legit guild/union (although you’re not absolutely sure if they are legits anyway)? Try to persuade the guildmaster to leave the union (although there are some familyties between the various guilds) and you don’t think that it will happen? Or carry on and ignore the union and just stick with your legit mates in that small and friendly guild?

Nyahgis · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 680 **Location:**

Finding a large legit union is difficult if not near impossible. I'd say stick with the current union. If you enjoy jobbing, grinding, or whatever you do within the union, then let that be your decision. Being part of a botting union doesn't nor should invalidate your own "morality."

Malicious · **Joined:** Dec 2007 **Posts:** 717 **Location:**

Nyahgis wrote:

Finding a large legit union is difficult if not near impossible. I'd say stick with the current union. If you enjoy jobbing, grinding, or whatever you do within the union, then let that be your decision. Being part of a botting union doesn't nor should invalidate your own "morality."

+1 all the way.

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

You could try to join Dukes_Union union.

Shimrod · **Joined:** Feb 2007 **Posts:** 336 **Location:**

Deacon wrote:

You could try to join Dukes_Union union.

huh?

Nyahgis · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 680 **Location:**

Shimrod wrote:

Deacon wrote:

You could try to join Dukes_Union union.

huh?

If you haven't noticed it yet, Deacon is rather proud of his all legit union. I think that he's suggesting that you join it.

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

Nyahgis wrote:

Shimrod wrote:

Deacon wrote:

You could try to join Dukes_Union union.

huh?

If you haven't noticed it yet, Deacon is rather proud of his all legit union. I think that he's suggesting that you join it.

Dukes_Union is not my union.. If he wanted a other union that is legit he could have tried to join Dukes_Union

Nyahgis · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 680 **Location:**

Deacon wrote:

Dukes_Union is not my union.. If he wanted a other union that is legit he could have tried to join Dukes_Union

My mistake, I thought your union was on Oasis [judging by the fact you guys both had Oasis flags,] and that you thus reffered to it. Now I'm just confused.

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

Nyahgis wrote:

Deacon wrote:

Dukes_Union is not my union.. If he wanted a other union that is legit he could have tried to join Dukes_Union

My mistake, I thought your union was on Oasis [judging by the fact you guys both had Oasis flags,] and that you thus reffered to it. Now I'm just confused.

Yes I am on oasis. Yes I got a own union. But its full and I don't really recruit on forums. I just wanted to HELP him in his situation, if he wanted to switch union to a bit big active union. And one that is legit ( as far as I know )

Renton · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 621 **Location:**

Deacon wrote:

Nyahgis wrote:

Deacon wrote:

Dukes_Union is not my union.. If he wanted a other union that is legit he could have tried to join Dukes_Union

My mistake, I thought your union was on Oasis [judging by the fact you guys both had Oasis flags,] and that you thus reffered to it. Now I'm just confused.

Yes I am on oasis. Yes I got a own union. But its full and I don't really recruit on forums. I just wanted to HELP him in his situation, if he wanted to switch union to a bit big active union. And one that is legit ( as far as I know )

Yes we know that union is legit.(From what you said in your 100s of post on it) Is there a need to say that over and over? You seem like you want someone to say that thats a botting union?

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

Renton wrote:

Yes we know that union is legit.(From what you said in your 100s of post on it) Is there a need to say that over and over? You seem like you want someone to say that you're in a botting union?

I am NOT talking about my OWN union. I'm telling him that DUKES UNION is a LEGIT union on OASIS as far as I know and IF he wanted to swtich UNION he could JOIN them maybe!

Renton · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 621 **Location:**

I edited my post after I reread my post & your post. Chill. Caps wasnt needed. Caps doesn't get your point across.

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

Renton wrote:

I edited my post after I reread my post & your post. Chill. Caps wasnt needed. Caps doesn't get your point across.

Well I had to type it for the 3th time. I hoped you would understand it then

Renton · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 621 **Location:**

Deacon wrote:

Renton wrote:

I edited my post after I reread my post & your post. Chill. Caps wasnt needed. Caps doesn't get your point across.

Well I had to type it for the 3th time. I hoped you would understand it then

You do realize my post was edited before you posted yours? And I didn't read but the first and last post.

Shimrod · **Joined:** Feb 2007 **Posts:** 336 **Location:**

This isn't really helpfull as it doesn't solve my "problem". Never heard of the Dukes-Union. Anyway, the question is if you would leave a small friendly guild with legit members which is part of a larger botter union?

Sylhana · **Joined:** Mar 2007 **Posts:** 3467 **Location:**

Renton wrote:

I edited my post after I reread my post & your post. Chill. Caps wasnt needed. Caps doesn't get your point across.

Reading also helps prevents confusion :love:

.

Lets try to stay on topic please

. @Shimrod, stay in your guild, as long as you enjoy gaming with your friends in your legit guild, it wont matter how dodgy your union is.

MrBow · **Posted:** Tue Jan 22, 2008 9:18 am

Shimrod wrote:

This isn't really helpfull as it doesn't solve my "problem". Never heard of the Dukes-Union. Anyway, the question is if you would leave a small friendly guild with legit members which is part of a larger botter union?

It all depends on your ethics. You are against botters, but you have friends in your legit guild that is in a botting union. Hard dilemma. If you're going to depend on your ethics, I'd talk to your guild leader first to join a legit union.

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

Depends of what the MOST people think. If they say stay then stay, if they want to leave, leave

Shimrod · **Joined:** Feb 2007 **Posts:** 336 **Location:**

Deacon wrote:

Depends of what the MOST people think. If they say stay then stay, if they want to leave, leave

Wouldn't like to tear the guild apart

†erminal · **Joined:** Jun 2007 **Posts:** 1138 **Location:**

I'm in a guild with 2 of my best *internet* friends
Just us 3 and a turk that logs in here and there.
And no other guild I'd rather be in <3
*We could use some expansion though

, kind of sad for a level 5 guild*

Shimrod · **Joined:** Feb 2007 **Posts:** 336 **Location:**

†erminal wrote:

And no other guild I'd rather be in <3
*We could use some expansion though

, kind of sad for a level 5 guild*

hah, i'm not the only one! My thoughts exactly

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

Shimrod wrote:

Deacon wrote:

Depends of what the MOST people think. If they say stay then stay, if they want to leave, leave

Wouldn't like to tear the guild apart

Talk about it in guild chat, see what other people feel..

EsQuiRe · **Joined:** Sep 2006 **Posts:** 575 **Location:**

Leaving real life friends to hang with a bunch of strangers isnt always a good idea. If u find ur guild fun then unless ur union is deliberatly ksing u while u grind or kill u while u job, then i see no reason in leaving.

borat2 · **Posted:** Tue Jan 22, 2008 9:58 am

friends will remain friends especially when you know them in real life, changing a guild or union should not change much in the relation between you and your friends.
another big problem in silkroad, people consider you automatically as an enemy if you don`t belong in their union :banghead:

Nader · **Joined:** Sep 2007 **Posts:** 1591 **Location:**

what guild are you in?

Shimrod wrote:

Imagine you’re a member of small guild with only a few really active members (some have multiple chars) and some of those members are also well known to you in real life.
They have a lot of fun in guild chat and help eachother when necessary. And what’s important they are legits.
Now this guild is part of a Union with a lot of botters (some of them are proud of the fact if you read the union chat). What would you do?
Leave the guild thus abandoning your mates and join a legit guild/union (although you’re not absolutely sure if they are legits anyway)? Try to persuade the guildmaster to leave the union (although there are some familyties between the various guilds) and you don’t think that it will happen? Or carry on and ignore the union and just stick with your legit mates in that small and friendly guild?

heroo · **Joined:** Sep 2006 **Posts:** 6618 **Location:**

Come on man...

we're talking about Oasis here.

THERE IS NO LEGIT UNION IN OASIS!

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

heroo wrote:

Come on man...
we're talking about Oasis here.
THERE IS NO LEGIT UNION IN OASIS!

I'm sorry ?

heroo · **Joined:** Sep 2006 **Posts:** 6618 **Location:**

Deacon wrote:

heroo wrote:

Come on man...
we're talking about Oasis here.
THERE IS NO LEGIT UNION IN OASIS!

I'm sorry ?

come on Deacon...

sure some of your union is legit, but you should once go and check out Hotan Area and Karokarem :wink:

Deacon · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 4377 **Location:** De Dutch

heroo wrote:

Deacon wrote:

heroo wrote:

Come on man...
we're talking about Oasis here.
THERE IS NO LEGIT UNION IN OASIS!

I'm sorry ?

come on Deacon...

sure some of your union is legit, but you should once go and check out Hotan Area and Karokarem :wink:

Or you should.. And prove it. I've been their enough

heroo · **Joined:** Sep 2006 **Posts:** 6618 **Location:**

Deacon wrote:

Or you should.. And prove it. I've been their enough

i have nothing to prove. you believe what you want to believe

Silkroad Online Forums

Dilemma :/

Who is online