UnbeatableDevil wrote:
ranger4life wrote:
rogue only reduce one of them
CE reduces hp
DD reduces def
so i think rogue would survive
im sure CE reduces both hp and def. DD only reduces def.
well, it depends on wat the rogue is using. if he is using CE, he dies first. if he uses DD, wiz dies fast.
Actually a rogue in DD will die faster then one with CE (if their attacking). Sure CE has 50% hp reduce but the defense reduce is 40%(only on Pdef) while DD has 75% (on both P/Mdef)
the thing that keeps me alive as Xbower is my knockdowns + knockbacks it is possible for me to kill a party general without even gettin hit if im lucky. As dagger rogue you have very short range attacks and only Screw/Prick to stun and help you survive so even tho dagger rogues have more hp and faster/higher damage rate. Against monsters Xbow is still the best.
And now on to the wizard vs rogue part. The wizard will die faster then both kinds of rogue because of his very low HP and still not high Pdef. But if the wizard uses skills like bind/fear they can also kill without getting hit.
And against party Generals wizard are even easier dead compared to rogues because they mostly rely on "power hits" (1hit with high attack) which can get blocked and will make quite some difference. While a dagger rogue uses mostly combos so if a hit gets blocked it aint too bad and also you have a high chance of critting.
Xbow rogue also has a bit problem with the blocks and kill slower then daggers/wiz but they compensate it with long range and KD/KB to avoid getting hit much.
Got this from my own experience as Rogue/Bard since i can solo a hunter party giant with Xbow while i would die with daggers (if my wolf doesnt pull aggro).
but he is talking about what would happen if the gen was attacking them and the wiz/rogue was standing still