Silkroad Online Forums

Verfo · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 9:43 pm

CnC please

Phix · **Joined:** Mar 2008 **Posts:** 716 **Location:** Ephesus

ill be real honest with you,

this is one of the worst sigs i have seen in ages..

---sorry---

magisuns · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 9:53 pm

Phix wrote:

ill be real honest with you,

this is one of the worst sigs i have seen in ages..

---sorry---

now your gonna need to elaborate on that...just saying its bad is pointless, and the WORST? Honestly, i'd like to see you do better. This sig is in NO WAY horrible. Its just fairly basic.

Verfo mens... stop with the basic stuffs

Panu · **Joined:** Aug 2007 **Posts:** 3536 **Location:** Around

its ok but not good. corner text = nono.

Phix · **Joined:** Mar 2008 **Posts:** 716 **Location:** Ephesus

magisuns,

its as you said..

its to basic to be good..
text isnt balanced with that font/size/color
the black bar's arent the same size/hight etc. (witch is really disturbing)
the only thing i like is the BGcolor since they look fairly balanced.

anyways.

its my oppinion.
if i say that its the worst i've seen doesnt make it terrible does it.
it only makes it terrible in my opinion.

once again i apologize if i sounded really rude, didnt mean to just saying my opinion.

Kraq · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:02 pm

Phix wrote:

ill be real honest with you,

this is one of the worst sigs i have seen in ages..

---sorry---

Critiquing ftw?
Add why you dont like it..

And agreed with Magisuns.
It looks good, but it is basic :\

IceCrash · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:03 pm

lol, i like it a lot

I think the erm, highest border should be behind the render, would look cooler like that xD
Anyways i really like it ^^
About the comments towards you, i think you should just do some sig tuturials see if you can move on with the learning, afterall you started messing around with PS by the same time i did :o
cmon menz <3

Phix · **Joined:** Mar 2008 **Posts:** 716 **Location:** Ephesus

Kraq wrote:

Phix wrote:

ill be real honest with you,

this is one of the worst sigs i have seen in ages..

---sorry---

Critiquing ftl?
Add why you dont like it..

And agreed with Magisuns.
It looks good, but it is basic :\

SRF, shows if some1 posted while you were making a post, and you obviously made this post AFTER i posed my post, so next time read the whole topic please. as i already mantioned i nthe post above why i dont like it.

magisuns · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:04 pm

Phix wrote:

magisuns,

its as you said..

its to basic to be good..
text isnt balanced with that font/size/color
the black bar's arent the same size/hight etc. (witch is really disturbing)
the only thing i like is the BGcolor since they look fairly balanced.

anyways.

its my oppinion.
if i say that its the worst i've seen doesnt make it terrible does it.
it only makes it terrible in my opinion.

once again i apologize if i sounded really rude, didnt mean to just saying my opinion.

now thats what you should have posted in the first place >_>

Kraq · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:05 pm

Phix wrote:

Kraq wrote:

Phix wrote:

ill be real honest with you,

this is one of the worst sigs i have seen in ages..

---sorry---

Critiquing ftl?
Add why you dont like it..

And agreed with Magisuns.
It looks good, but it is basic :\

SRF, shows if some1 posted while you were making a post, and you obviously made this post AFTER i posed my post, so next time read the whole topic please. as i already mantioned i nthe post above why i dont like it.

I saw your post don't think I didn't.
Just reinforcing it, now you see you will always be reminded to back up your statement because of this

IceCrash wrote:

lol, i like it a lot

I think the erm, highest border should be behind the render, would look cooler like that xD
Anyways i really like it ^^
About the comments towards you, i think you should just do some sig tuturials see if you can move on with the learning, afterall you started messing around with PS by the same time i did :o
cmon menz <3

There is no render...The people are a part of the background so unless Verfo wants to cut it out,it can't be done :]

Phix · **Joined:** Mar 2008 **Posts:** 716 **Location:** Ephesus

oke well sorry for not posting my critics straight away..

that was my last post here..

^^

*leaves thread*

magisuns · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:07 pm

KRAQ Uwe SCARED HIM AWAY

and look at the sig i made for phanta again >_>

Verfo · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:27 pm

its that bad

IceCrash · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:29 pm

Verfo wrote:

its that bad

it isnt mate
<3

Verfo · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:33 pm

i guess i need to do more tuts instead of discovering myself

IceCrash · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:36 pm

Verfo wrote:

i guess i need to do more tuts instead of discovering myself

yeah mate, seriously, it helps a lot

MasterKojito · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:38 pm

Phix wrote:

magisuns,

its as you said..

its to basic to be good..
text isnt balanced with that font/size/color
the black bar's arent the same size/hight etc. (witch is really disturbing)
the only thing i like is the BGcolor since they look fairly balanced.

anyways.

its my oppinion.
if i say that its the worst i've seen doesnt make it terrible does it.
it only makes it terrible in my opinion.

once again i apologize if i sounded really rude, didnt mean to just saying my opinion.

Apart from the weird border, the sig is great. I'm sorry to inform you, but simple =/= bad. Go look a reks current sig. It is simple and yet, still very artistic and good. I think the sig could use some work to fix it up a bit (play with burn and blur :wink:

) but it is nice overall.

Also before acting like you know something about sigs, art, or w/e, can I ask to see your works?

magisuns · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 10:45 pm

Verfo... ITS NOT BADDDDD
dont let someone who probably cant even make a sig get to u
its just basic and simple. But it STILL LOOKS GOOD

heck look at my sig and ava right now... its so simple its not even funny. But simple doesnt mean bad
But its not like i can help it... its only my 3rd day with photoshop :oops:

IceCrash · **Posted:** Sun Sep 21, 2008 11:03 pm

yeah...
some ppl are like
"ZOMG BUT, IT NID C4D, IT NID EFFECT RANDAZZZZZZZZ, IT NEEDS MOAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR PICCCCCCCSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS"
Just do it like a real thing, imagine it's for real, or even better, fu.ck whatever everyone else thinks and do whatever you like mate

Seriously, dont let yourself go down just because of this, this stuff is related to art, art is normally very wierd, why, because there can't be a "right" opinion for it.
So it HAS to be, You like it? Awsome.
Otherwise, if you're gonna be depending on other ppl's opinions, you're for sure gonna give up

Barotix · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 9250 **Location:** Sand

learning on your own is more fun. Tuts always confuse me. >_> I just ask questions or test stuff to see what does what and simple is beautiful imo. Look at .rek's sig. hawt. I still don't know how to use the pen tool. :banghead:

7/10

MasterKojito · **Posted:** Mon Sep 22, 2008 1:08 am

Barotix wrote:

learning on your own is more fun. Tuts always confuse me. >_> I just ask questions or test stuff to see what does what and simple is beautiful imo. Look at .rek's sig. hawt. I still don't know how to use the pen tool. :banghead:

7/10

pen tool=point and click

Verfo · **Posted:** Mon Sep 22, 2008 1:45 am

pen tool is way to confusing

MasterKojito · **Posted:** Mon Sep 22, 2008 2:45 am

Anyways I fixed your sig for you

Its a collab now :wink:

Verfo · **Posted:** Mon Sep 22, 2008 3:11 am

MasterKojito wrote:

Anyways I fixed your sig for you

Its a collab now :wink:

DarkJackal · **Joined:** Feb 2006 **Posts:** 6119 **Location:** A den~

I think its a pretty good sig really. Corner text is fine to me.

The only thing I think should be changed is the black bars at the top and bottom aren't the same size.

rek · **Posted:** Mon Sep 22, 2008 11:08 am

Phix wrote:

ill be real honest with you,

this is one of the worst sigs i have seen in ages..

---sorry---

...come on man. Even if i don't like something i don't say it like that. </3

Ot: The borders looks too thick. But nice and simple, kiu.

Priam · **Posted:** Mon Sep 22, 2008 11:54 am

Not bad at all, i lol'd at the comments provided by the one whom said it was.

Melez · **Posted:** Mon Sep 22, 2008 6:10 pm

Simple and nice. The borders are thick though. :love:

Kraq · **Posted:** Mon Sep 22, 2008 10:49 pm

I personally like how the top is bigger than the bottom because it just feels like the ending of a movie or like when you get sleepy your eye lid droops down. The pic just has that movie ending feel. So the stroke kinda fits

Verfo · **Posted:** Tue Sep 23, 2008 3:38 am

10 Confidence gained!

Silkroad Online Forums

NSR

Who is online