Rate the sig above yours

Noobs_Slayer · **Joined:** Jan 2008 **Posts:** 1196 **Location:** AioN

vietxboy911 wrote:

6/10

1 5/10
2 8/10

Amarisa · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 4049 **Location:** Magic

vietxboy911 · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 3236 **Location:**

5.5/10

DarkestMagicks · **Joined:** Aug 2009 **Posts:** 44 **Location:** Flanders

7.5/10
8/10

Again >.<

I want feedback on my new sig

Noobs_Slayer · **Joined:** Jan 2008 **Posts:** 1196 **Location:** AioN

DarkestMagicks wrote:

7.5/10
8/10

Again >.<

I want feedback on my new sig

I am sorry what i am going to say right now.
The score is... 5/10
It seems like you didn't put much effort to your sig. I don't see any effects, and Background is slightly oversharpened, no deph in it. With that render you could do awesome sig.

DarkestMagicks · **Joined:** Aug 2009 **Posts:** 44 **Location:** Flanders

Don't be sorry

What about this one? The apehead might be a bit too dark ;o

Changed my mind about yours, 9/10, first I gave it an 8 but as I've seen some real work of arts here, they'd be 8 and yours 9 :banghead:

.

Noobs_Slayer · **Joined:** Jan 2008 **Posts:** 1196 **Location:** AioN

DarkestMagicks wrote:

Don't be sorry

What about this one? The apehead might be a bit too dark ;o

Changed my mind about yours, 9/10, first I gave it an 8 but as I've seen some real work of arts here, they'd be 8 and yours 9 :banghead:

.

Offtopic: I made my sig while i was high
OnT: I like this render so it will be 7/10, add some effects and flow

chrisorg · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 872 **Location:**

6.9/10

DarkestMagicks · **Joined:** Aug 2009 **Posts:** 44 **Location:** Flanders

9/10
7.5/10

Crowley · **Posted:** Thu Aug 20, 2009 3:46 am

6/10

Not my cup of tea

DarkestMagicks · **Joined:** Aug 2009 **Posts:** 44 **Location:** Flanders

6/10

Too light, and the text is kinda painful to read.

Thomas42 · **Posted:** Thu Aug 20, 2009 6:20 pm

I'd say about 6.5-7/10
MAybe it's just me, but the render isn't really blended.

chrisorg · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 872 **Location:**

6/10

What can I say, Im on a smudging spree lol

rumpleKillskin · **Joined:** Jun 2007 **Posts:** 1934 **Location:**

For the first sig, 8.5/10.

For the daft one, 10/10 ;P

FireVortex · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 2005 **Location:**

7/10
7/10

Amarisa · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 4049 **Location:** Magic

first 7/10
quote 10/10 XD
2nd 10/10 <3 that one

Thomas42 · **Posted:** Tue Aug 25, 2009 4:44 am

I'd give it a 6-6.5/10 considering it's your 8th sig ever.

me haz new signitshur raet pl0x

Amarisa · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 4049 **Location:** Magic

Thomas42 wrote:

I'd give it a 6-6.5/10 considering it's your 8th sig ever.

me haz new signitshur raet pl0x

6-6.5 is the same as what i got with my 4th lol what would it be if you didn't count it was my 8th?

also 9/10 <3 kenshin (i dont think i spelled it right @.@ its been so long)

XemnasXD · **Posted:** Tue Aug 25, 2009 5:38 am

6.9/10

i see stuff and it looks nice but i don't see the concept...just seems like things were thrown in..

Thomas42 · **Posted:** Tue Aug 25, 2009 6:34 am

@Amarisa
8th sig is only 4 sigs after 4th. In your thread you said in three of them you were just testing stuff, while the last was half-assed, as you said. I, too, have a ton of failsigs on my PC, in which I just tested stuff, followed tutorials and all that. Don't get discouraged by a few low rates; I got them too, a lot. In fact you were the first person who rated meh sig over 7/10. If you feel like it, make a few sigs based on tutorials, and when you think you got the base of that particular tut, make your own addition/changes to it. oh and if I didn't count it is your 8th sig, the rate would probably be around the same, or a tiny bit lower.

@Xemnas
Hostage sig, automatic 15/10.
edit - or is that just a quote? Nvm, awesome stuff anyway.

also, I require moar rates

Amarisa · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 4049 **Location:** Magic

Thomas42 wrote:

@Amarisa
8th sig is only 4 sigs after 4th. In your thread you said in three of them you were just testing stuff, while the last was half-assed, as you said. I, too, have a ton of failsigs on my PC, in which I just tested stuff, followed tutorials and all that. Don't get discouraged by a few low rates; I got them too, a lot. In fact you were the first person who rated meh sig over 7/10. If you feel like it, make a few sigs based on tutorials, and when you think you got the base of that particular tut, make your own addition/changes to it. oh and if I didn't count it is your 8th sig, the rate would probably be around the same, or a tiny bit lower.

@Xemnas
Hostage sig, automatic 15/10.
edit - or is that just a quote? Nvm, awesome stuff anyway.

also, I require moar rates

well after Noobs_Slayer bashed the hell out of it i decided ill make another one

and do i have to rate again? XD

you would still get a 9/10 lol

DarkestMagicks · **Joined:** Aug 2009 **Posts:** 44 **Location:** Flanders

I agree with 6.5/10. I don't like the one-colored-ness.

I'm guessing you used a gradient map? I've tried using it a few times but I never got anything useful with it =/. I expect it's cos of my own noobiness though.

Thomas, I know it's not my turn but I agree your sig is really really nice

.

Noobs_Slayer · **Joined:** Jan 2008 **Posts:** 1196 **Location:** AioN

6/10 You getting better. I see some low quality {which included in my works as well}, Some parts is too brigth, no Light source. But it's way better than previous one.

Amarisa · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 4049 **Location:** Magic

DarkestMagicks wrote:

I agree with 6.5/10. I don't like the one-colored-ness.

I'm guessing you used a gradient map? I've tried using it a few times but I never got anything useful with it =/. I expect it's cos of my own noobiness though.

Thomas, I know it's not my turn but I agree your sig is really really nice

.

the 6.5/10 was for my 8th sig lol NS here ruined my specialness >:o

nope i just took a brush and covered the whole thing left to right. then smudged it put what i think is also called a C4D (not sure if it is or not). put the night elf then i had another layer here that i'm sure not many of you can tell. a brush that is not really thick in color (so you can see through it) then smudged it also lol.

anyways 0/10 spoilers are boring

satman83 · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 9541 **Location:** London

chrisorg · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 872 **Location:**

8/10 Love the banana lol

CrimsonNuker · **Joined:** Aug 2006 **Posts:** 13791 **Location:**

FireVortex · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 2005 **Location:**

6/10

For ur avy >9000 :love:

Amarisa · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 4049 **Location:** Magic

FireVortex wrote:

6/10

For ur avy >9000 :love:

oh no you didn't!

anyways still the same scoring your didn't change lol

Noobs_Slayer · **Joined:** Jan 2008 **Posts:** 1196 **Location:** AioN

I'll give 6/10 to cheer ya up.
Some suggestions:
Use more than 1 C4D (download some effect C4d),
In every sig make light source (with Soft round whiteor other color)
Try to make flow of C4D's that you mixed up in your works, keep trying

Silkroad Online Forums

Rate the sig above yours

Who is online