Tsume wrote:
"I'm not your everyday guy, trying to persuade you to join not your everyday club"
Although your original sentence can be conceived as an abnormal guy trying to persuade an audience to join an abnormal clue, it can be structured differently to lessen some confusion:
"I'm not an everyday guy trying to persuade you to join an everyday type of club."
This can be conceived as an abnormal guy trying to persuade an audience to join an abnormal club; shown by the fact that you're NOT a normal guy trying to persuade them to join a normal, everyday type of club.
Small grammatical changes can go a long way.
_________________

Quote:
We should stop treating people like objects, or at least treat our objects with more respect.